Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent
#3 Insurance Agents in Alexandria@matthew-mccarthy-geico-insurance-agent-4oof on Google Business
Data from 1 month ago
www.geico.comInsurance Agency
538
Reviews
4.5
Rating
Quality
RateXYZ metric
538
Total Reviews
7
Photos
Business Digest
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent is a Insurance Agents on Google Business with 538 reviews and an average rating of 4.5. Their RateXYZ trust score is 37/100. Located in Alexandria, United States. View on Google Maps.
They're 462 reviews away from reaching the 1,000 reviews milestone.
Ranked #3 among all businesses in Alexandria.
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent Analytics Overview
Reviews Change
+0
↑ vs prev period
Growth Rate
+0.00%
↑ vs prev period
Avg Rating
4.5
Reviews Growth
Average Rating Trend
Latest Reviews
Anonymous
Emilee/ Emily was extremely professional and helpful throughout the entire auto insurance process. She took the time to understand my needs, explained everything clearly, and helped me secure a great policy at an excellent price. Her responsiveness and knowledge made the experience easy and stress-free, and I highly recommend her to anyone looking for quality auto insurance.
4 months ago
Anonymous
I have never experienced treatment like this before. I called this agency on January 21, 2026, at approximately 12:10 PM to ask about the insurance price for my car. A person answered, and his manner of speaking was extremely rude. He didn’t even try to explain the available offers patiently; instead, he spoke very fast. When I asked if there was any additional discount since I found a better offer elsewhere, he said no, as if he didn’t want to continue the conversation. He then said goodbye and hung up on me. I have never encountered such rudeness in my life. Because of him, I was forced to sign up with another agency.
5 months ago
Anonymous
A guy inside this office called Juan Zavala has aggressive attitude towards customers. Very rude and have no manners. We called him for a new quote and he said full coverage is $$$. Then, we told him ok we will pay it. Then he declined the application because he want us to do liability. And then, he said “have a good day” I am not going to do it for you”. Is there a manager that we can talk about this and review the cameras. Because this guy shouldn’t be there.
8 months ago
Photos
7 totalMatthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent Growth Analytics
7 Days
+0
+0.00%
30 Days
+0
+0.00%
90 Days
+0
+0.00%
Reviews Timeline
Daily Reviews Change
Rating Trend
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent Growth Projections
30d
538
90% confidence
90d
538
80% confidence
1y
538
65% confidence
5y
538
40% confidence
Reviews Milestones
50 Reviews
100 Reviews
250 Reviews
500 Reviews
1K Reviews
2.5K Reviews
5K Reviews
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent Services
No Services Available
This business hasn't listed any services yet.
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent Google Reviews
538 reviews
Google User
Emilee/ Emily was extremely professional and helpful throughout the entire auto insurance process. She took the time to understand my needs, explained everything clearly, and helped me secure a great policy at an excellent price. Her responsiveness and knowledge made the experience easy and stress-free, and I highly recommend her to anyone looking for quality auto insurance.
Google User
I have never experienced treatment like this before. I called this agency on January 21, 2026, at approximately 12:10 PM to ask about the insurance price for my car. A person answered, and his manner of speaking was extremely rude. He didn’t even try to explain the available offers patiently; instead, he spoke very fast. When I asked if there was any additional discount since I found a better offer elsewhere, he said no, as if he didn’t want to continue the conversation. He then said goodbye and hung up on me. I have never encountered such rudeness in my life. Because of him, I was forced to sign up with another agency.
Google User
A guy inside this office called Juan Zavala has aggressive attitude towards customers. Very rude and have no manners. We called him for a new quote and he said full coverage is $$$. Then, we told him ok we will pay it. Then he declined the application because he want us to do liability. And then, he said “have a good day” I am not going to do it for you”. Is there a manager that we can talk about this and review the cameras. Because this guy shouldn’t be there.
Google User
I just purchased a renter’s insurance policy through Emilee Gorski at GEICO for my son who is going to JMU, and I could not be more impressed with the experience. Emilee was professional, knowledgeable, and incredibly helpful in walking me through the process. She took the time to explain everything clearly, answer all of my questions, and made sure we had the right coverage in place. Her friendly and approachable manner made what could have been a stressful process feel simple and easy. I truly appreciate her excellent service and highly recommend her to anyone looking for insurance support!
Google User
Excellent service provided by Emilee Gorski. She was very easy and pleasant to talk to, I was all set up and ready to go with my new car insurance in less than 10 mins. She really knows her stuff, very very knowledgeable and clearly explains the different policies to you. Definitely going to follow up with her for other forms of insurance needed. Highly recommend!
Questions & Answers
No questions yet. Be the first to ask!
Asked by ·
Business response
Quick Actions
Business Details
- Platform
- Google Business
- Phone
- (703) 236-1366
- Address
- 4617 Duke St, Alexandria, VA 22304, USA
- Hours
- 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
- 30d Growth
- +0.00%
- Last Updated
- 1 month ago
Monday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Tuesday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Wednesday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Thursday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Friday: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
Data sourced from Google and refreshed periodically. Ratings and reviews are not endorsed by RateXYZ.
Get Notified
Get updates when this profile's stats change significantly.
Get in Touch
Typically responds within 24hrs
Interested in Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent? Send an enquiry and they'll get back to you.
Similar Businesses
Embed Badge
Show your RateXYZ rating on your website.
Is this your profile?
Claim it to unlock audience insights, enhanced analytics & more.
Claim This Profile
Send Enquiry
to Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent
Enquiry Sent!
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent will receive your enquiry and get back to you soon.
Your Contact Details
We'll share this with the business so they can respond.
What's your enquiry about?
Tell the business what you're looking for.
Matthew McCarthy - GEICO Insurance Agent
4.5★ · 538 reviews